Welcome to Citarella Gourmet Market - Upper East Side
Citarella Gourmet Market - Upper East Side is a culinary haven that embodies the essence of gourmet shopping. Nestled in the heart of New York, this market is revered for its exceptional selection of fresh seafood, high-quality meats, and farm-fresh produce. It is a destination where variety meets quality, ensuring that every recipe finds its perfect match. Patrons rave about the meticulous sourcing strategy and consistent freshness—from handcrafted chicken meatballs bursting with flavor to the exquisite white sturgeon caviar. With attentive staff and a vibrant atmosphere, Citarella stands out as a cherished staple for both everyday needs and gourmet indulgences.
-
1313 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10021 Hotline: (212) 874-0383
Welcome to the bustling heart of New York City, where culinary excellence meets community charm at Citarella Gourmet Market - Upper East Side. Nestled at 1313 3rd Ave, this gourmet haven is not just a seafood market; it's an experience for food lovers seeking the finest produce, meats, and artisanal goods.
Citarella is renowned for its commitment to quality and freshness. A frequent patron, Christine H., highlights the market’s exceptional sourcing strategy, suggesting it offers a remarkable variety of specialty items. It’s a place where enthusiasts can find niche ingredients often absent in larger supermarkets. Whether you're hunting for a specific breed of orange or that elusive pumpkin, Citarella has you covered.
For seafood aficionados, the freshness at Citarella is legendary. Patrons rave about the superior quality of fish, comparing it favorably to competitors, and it's clear that attention to detail is a priority here. The market offers a selection of the finest seafood, promising to delight every palate. Moreover, the prepped meals, like the Asian Chicken and Eggplant Parmigiana, are perfect for those looking for convenience without sacrificing quality.
The poultry and beef selections shine as well. From the mouthwatering Guiseppe's Chicken Meatballs to the succulent Beef Pot Roast, every dish is crafted with care. Looking for something simple yet delightful? The Chicken Milanese or Buffalo Chicken Wings are crowd favorites that never disappoint. As you meander through the aisles, the well-organized shelves filled with artisanal cheeses and fresh fruits tempt you at every turn.
- Location: 1313 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10021
- Phone: (212) 874-0383
- Specialties: Fresh seafood, gourmet prepped meals, artisanal cheeses, fresh produce
While some might consider Citarella on the pricier side, the general consensus is that the quality justifies the cost. Many customers, like Lawrence S. and Robert G., affirm that the market often provides competitive pricing on essential items, making it a smart choice for discerning shoppers.
Additionally, the atmosphere is welcoming, enriched by the dedication of the staff. Many customers, including Pamela P. and Robin's Hood X., appreciate the personalized service, noting how staff members go out of their way to meet specific requests and provide assistance with orders. This commitment to customer satisfaction adds to the overall experience.
In conclusion, Citarella Gourmet Market - Upper East Side isn’t just about shopping; it’s about community and a shared love for quality food. Whether you are a local or just visiting, this market invites you to explore its vibrant variety and exquisite offerings. As you make your selection, remember that each bite reflects a passion for food that is woven deeply into the fabric of this extraordinary market.
I will die on my grave saying that Citarella is the best supermarket in the area. A few reasons why I believe this: 1. Variety For a smaller supermarket, they have just about everything you would need. I'm always so pleasantly surprised when they have the niche pumpkin or specific breed of orange I need for my recipes. I'm almost shocked that other supermarkets contain SO much, yet nothing. I hope others can follow Citarellas sourcing strategy because it is VERY good. 2. Fresh Produce, Meat, and Seafood Firstly, the fruits here are surprisingly delicious. Every time I've picked up any fruit, I'm always pleasantly amazed. The meat and seafood is also the freshest I've seen. I know that there have been some off days when the seafood hasn't been as fresh, but overall I've still had a lot more consistency here than at nearby stores. Yes, the salmon at Whole foods is 7.99 a pound but why is it gray? 3. Price People who say Citarella is pricey are not wrong. However, if you stray away from the 40$ artisanal chips and the made-to-order food I find that Citarella is honestly very fairly priced. I often run around the neighborhood to compare prices and let me tell you, Citarella is often the cheapest for staple items like lemons or eggs. They do lack in items like vanilla extract (I believe Citarella only carries one brand and it's 16.99 which ok yes i agree that is insane). I'm not saying they have trader joe deals, but this place is often cheaper than Whole Foods, Gristedes, and Morton Williams for your basic items. Now, a few improvements: 1. could stock more asian items and also star anise (the one staple i believe does not exist at Citarella) 2. could have smaller cheese servings so I don't have to pay 1lb of parmesan every time for my single serve pasta dish 3. could have normal priced flour Otherwise, this place is the best !
Citarella is an upper east side staple and for good reason. When needing gourmet items its a good spot. Consistently reliable quality, fresh seafood, their prepped meals are good, welcoming staff which makes for a fun experience. High quality fresh fruits and artisan cheeses. Quite pricey but to be expected for the area and quality, Got several items for a quick tasting board, their white sturgeon caviar is great quality! The store is well stocked and kept clean! Will revisit again!
This place is very dependable, always stocked and the items are fresh and the shelves are organized. I swear 3rd ave in general is a wanna be Madison lol but I love to come here for the baguettes. They are so tasty. Some of the staff are nice some are nonchalant I get it. The decor is great though. I love their branding.
I wish Citarella had some competition because there would be more places like this around New York - but "alas," it's either Third Avenue or Broadway (I never go to their Sith Avenue location)... and they're in a class by themselves. Joe carries the best: from vegetables to meat and seafood. Try the Russian tea cookies. I could complain about the prices but prices are high everywhere. And for a bit more $$$ than D'Agostino's you get the best there is. My recommendation is to go with your recipe ingredient list and don't veer too far afield or you'll be tempted to squander your children's college tuition.
Just a quick shout-out to Store Manager, Vladimir. Thank you, Vlad, for going out of your way to fulfill my request--as well as for keeping an eye out on store operations, making sure that displays look beautiful and everything is running smoothly! (I was looking for something missing from the produce shelves, and Vladimir pointed out that a delivery truck had just arrived, and if I waited a few minutes, he would actually check the truck to see if it had my item...He found it on board the truck, and I left the store very happy! That's service--and with a smile no less!) Even though this is only supposed to be a shout-out to Vlad, since I'm writing this, I might as well mention my biggest gripe with the store: The prepared foods section. It truly needs a reworking. Nothing ever looks appetizing. Management should take a look at Butterfield's, among others, to make note of their prepared foods offerings, presentation, and service. I'll leave it at that....
Great place for fresh seafood, friendly staff that will help you clean and cut your fish as wanted and the best prices in the area. Cannot be happy enough to have such amazing store at walking distance.